League of Legends Wiki

Comments38

A Buff for Melee Carries

ClariS January 28, 2013 User blog:ClariS

Ad blocker interference detected!


Wikia is a free-to-use site that makes money from advertising. We have a modified experience for viewers using ad blockers

Wikia is not accessible if you’ve made further modifications. Remove the custom ad blocker rule(s) and the page will load as expected.

Introduction

Currently in the game, there are four champions that are classified as melee carries. They are Fiora Fiora, Gangplank Gangplank, Master Yi Master Yi, and Tryndamere Tryndamere. As most people who follows and watches the E-sport of League of Legends, none of these champions are played (the expectation is Yi but that's because people play him as an assassin).

Some More Information about Melee Carries

They are classify as a melee carry, meaning, they were ideally designed to dish out a lot of DPS through basic attacks at melee range. Because of that, they hit two wall blocks in why a class like this is really big.

  • The first reason is: Because they provide high DPS, they are high priority targets.
  • The second reason is: Because their core build cost tends to be high, they tend to be fairly squishy.

Now, I want to say that I think the season 3 re-work helped the melee AD carry overall for two reasons:

  • Health is easier to get, and generally this is the only form of defense melee carry will only grab, so the difference between bruisers and melee carries are less different.
  • Health is more easier to counter through DPS then it is through burst damage (this is something that should favor them over bruiser overall)

But even with this, I still think melee carries need a slight improvement before they, as a class is ever really viable in the game.


So My Suggestion

Now, there is many factors why they aren't played often, but I, today, want to talk about one thing and why it's an issue. A strong core item for their class.

And my suggestion, in my belief, doesn't seem that radical, but rather, seems to make sense as Riot has done this before to make a class, as a whole, more viable. Some people might not know about this, but roughly a year ago, the meta was all about tanky melee champions and carries were useless, so in order to boost the effectiveness of the carry class, they made B. F. Sword item.png B. F. Sword more cost efficient plus it's upgraded items. After that patch, there was a huge resurgent of that class. The same can be said for mages that were required to jump in the middle of teamfights. When Zhonya's Hourglass item.png Zhonya's Hourglass was buffed, we saw champions like Morgana Morgana and Kennen Kennen be played again in tournaments.

And so, I think the same thing should be done with Melee Carries.

But wait, someone might ask. What item can Riot possibly change to improve that very small class without effecting the balance of the other classes. And for those, I present Youmuu's Ghostblade item.png Youmuu's Ghostblade:

NOTE: I'm not forgetting about Ravenous Hydra item.png Ravenous Hydra, but this item falls under the issue that even bruisers can use this item rather effectively.

Youmuu's Ghostblade

This item is a rather good item that is very underused, but for a good reason. Without it's activate, it really isn't that cost efficient or slot efficient. By itself, it doesn't provide much damage and it's there other items that are better than it.

With that in mind, this is my suggestion to improve this item viability for melee champions.

Youmuu's Ghostblade.gif
Availability
S T D P
Youmuu's Ghostblade
"{{{title}}}"
Cost: 2500 gold
Sell Value 1750
Item Code 3142
Unique Active: Gain +40% attack speed and +20% movement speed for 7 seconds (4 seconds for ranged champions) - 45 second cooldown. Stats
+25 attack damage
+25% critical strike chance
+10% cooldown reduction
Unique: +10 armor penetration
Recipe
Avarice Blade item+The Brutalizer item+
Emptylord Greed
363g
Transparent
Changes Made
  • Total Cost decrease to 2500 from 2700
  • Attack Damage decrease to 25 from 30
  • Critical Chance increase to 25% from 15%
  • Armor Penetration decrease to 10 from 20
  • Activate duration increase to 7 seconds from 6 seconds


Reasoning

The changes I made have their reasoning. They are:

  • Straight damage is not something melee carries are in great need of. If you notice, all the melee champions gain free Attack Damage. Therefore, they don't need that much AD in one item.
  • This isn't supposed to be the first item anyone rushes. It would be kind of stupid to force that into any role when considering that this item builds out from a Gp10 item. Let alone, there is so many stats attached to it.
  • It's cheaper overall so this allows melee carries to grab their defensive items a but quicker then their range counter-parts.
    • This item is supposed to replaced PD, or Statiki, or Zerphy in a core build. This item is supposed to be build around IE, or BT.
  • Range champions still can't use the activate effect that well, so PD, Statiki, and Zerphy will still look like the more attractive choice (I hope).
  • Critical chance is a stat that only champions based on auto-attacking champions will only desired. Casters, assassins, and bruisers rarely ever want this stat, making this item not really affecting them.
    • So overall, the total efficiency of this item for them has either not changed or gone down.

Conclusion

So, what's your thoughts and opinions to making this class more viable in tournament play?

Also on Fandom

Random Wiki